Back to Learn

THE CONDITIONS · PARTS THREE, FOUR AND FIVE The Price of Trust | Open Position by Steven Feldman

OPEN POSITION

FROM THE DESK OF STEVEN FELDMAN

For the longest time, America borrowed cheaply, defended expansively and got to write most of the global rules. What happens as trust in America erodes?

For my entire adult life, America has had an enviable arrangement. Borrow from the rest of the world to help drive powerful domestic demand for global exports. Defend that same world, even if it required using a big chunk of those borrowed funds to do so. Use that economic and military might to extend its global influence. Rinse and repeat.

It all worked because of one simple secret ingredient – trust. Trust that allies would remain allies, that free trade would remain free, and that risk-free credit would remain risk-free. The international community is now having “trust issues.”

That’s abroad. Back on our shores, American voters just expressed their own trust issues with the White House. They had the three issues listed above on their dance card, but atop their list was the trust that wars would be well thought out and that politicians would govern instead of monetize. This mistrust led them to decide to change who supervises the White House. This new check may help rebuild global trust in the US. That’s the good news. But a new Congress means that the rules may change once again. And that vote did nothing for the country’s finances. Those votes belong to the bondholders.

This newsletter is the third in a series called The Conditions. Originally, it was supposed to be a five-part series. But in the interest of brevity, I am combining Parts Three, Four and Five into this one letter – covering the “referee,” the “umbrella” and the mighty dollar. Three standalone installments would have been a lot to ask of you, and frankly, of me. A quick recap: Part One was the setup. The conditions investors take for granted are durable, not inevitable. Conditions change regardless of our desire for them to stay the same, or our tendency to think of them as a pendulum that swings back after you just bought the dip. Part Two talked about contracts and property rights, claiming that they are not as sacrosanct as they used to be.

I asked myself whether the “Blue Wave” might alter these new conditions. Maybe. But not by much. So here goes.

THE REFEREE HAS A POSITION

Arthur Levitt, who ran the SEC and whom I later became friends with, pushed through Regulation FD in 2000. It said that a public company can’t whisper market-moving news to favored analysts and big investors before telling everybody else. Whether you were for or against that rule, there was nary a soul on Wall Street who suspected that Levitt had his personal dog in the fight. He was the referee, not a player or, worse yet, a bettor.

Now consider what another government official, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, told a crowd at Southern Methodist University on September 8. “I am the house now.” He was talking about the yen. “You can bet against me if you want,” he said. “I have asymmetric information.” The Treasury owes more than $40 trillion. It has been buying back its own long bonds in bigger and bigger bites. In July it worked with Japan to buy yen in a way that did not require Japan to sell Treasuries. And it is writing the rules for stablecoins, whose issuers are required to hold Treasuries.

Governments have always meddled with currencies and their own debt, and this started before him. But when the world’s biggest borrower is buying its own bonds, preventing other countries from selling theirs, and creating a murky financial product just to buy even more Treasuries, I stop knowing what a price is telling me. A casino at least posts its rules on the wall.

THE UMBRELLA HAS A BILL

The Pentagon’s January strategy says allies should carry their own weight. Then in August the United States and South Korea called off a big amphibious drill, and Washington blamed the Iran war for stretching its forces. My guess is that this is less strategy than overstretch, but if you are the ally, the effect is the same. I don’t think Europe can defend itself without Washington, and I don’t think Europe believes it can count on Washington either. Both can be true.

Here is a dynamic that now seems broken. For decades, countries that sheltered under our security also piled up our bonds. Nobody wrote that down as a deal. Nobody sent an invoice. But it is hard to believe that one didn’t help the other. So if you are told to spend a lot more on your own defense, do you still have money left for Treasuries? If you trust Washington a little less, do you hold a bit fewer Treasuries? Probably.

THE SAVERS HAVE OPTIONS

The dollar doesn’t have to fail. It only has to get a little more problematic for America to slowly lose its privileges. Think like a central banker who has to invest a few hundred billion dollars of a country’s savings. You probably won’t dump Treasuries in a wholesale fashion. You just want a little less than you used to. But someone still has to buy them. Maybe yields go up because there is a tad less global demand. Maybe domestic investors pick up the slack, enticed by its history as the risk-free asset and a few extra pre-tax basis points. No crisis, just a higher price for a habit we have had for decades.

The arithmetic does not care who chairs the committees. The CBO has us running a deficit of roughly $2 trillion this year, adding another 5% to a $40 trillion debt in a single year. Those same rates that enticed the domestic buyer? They show up as interest expense on the country’s income statement. More than $1 trillion and counting. What is Congress going to do about that? Cut spending? Increase taxes? These are politicians who need to be re-elected, some every two years. We shall see, but keep your hands up and protect yourself at all times.

SO WHAT DO I DO ABOUT IT

Broken record time. I am never going to recommend that anyone abandon the S&P 500, which gets reconstituted to find the winners in a way that no single investor who only buys individual stocks could hope to match (and in an ETF, the rebalancing is tax-free!). With that said, the broken record skips to this: diversify into things that don’t depend on a government’s promise to be worth something.

Treasuries are right in the crosshairs. It’s all government. Yup, the yield has gotten juicier and there is even a chance for appreciation if there is disinflation that comes with the end of the wars in Iran and Ukraine, as well as a lessening of tariffs. But for a taxable investor, you will barely break even with inflation even in the best case.

And there is hardly an industry that is not impacted by government. All the more reason to stay diversified, and try to find industries/companies/stocks that have both tangible value and scarcity.

The next record skip: gold. No issuer, but also no coupon. That hasn’t stopped central banks, especially China, from buying like crazy. But who wants to invest like a central bank? I do. At least when it comes to protecting my nest egg. So it’s an allocation, not a recommendation to sell everything and buy bullion.

To be clear, I don’t expect the dollar to lose its reserve status. Just like I don’t expect our allies to walk away. I just don’t like having my nest egg depend on it.

American voters changed the people supervising the government. That is democracy. The people financing the government get a vote too. I am casting mine differently.

Steven Feldman

Co-Founder & CEO, GBI and Wealthion

This newsletter is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. GBI and Wealthion clients should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Wealthion is a dba of Greylock Peak Investments, a registered investment adviser. This newsletter is general information only. It is not investment advice or an offer or solicitation, and it is not tailored to your circumstances. Guests’ views are their own and may not reflect those of Wealthion. Wealthion has not verified guest statements, including any performance figures. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Wealthion refers readers to other registered investment advisers and shares in the fees they receive from referred clients, which creates a conflict of interest. Please see our Form ADV Part 2A, and consult your own financial advisor before investing.

Investment Insights

What Serious Investors Are Watching

Dive into expert interviews, market analysis, and long-form content built to help serious investors think long-term.

Explore More
Macro Bites – Metals Supply Tightens as Oil Shipping Costs Fall
Article

Macro Bites – Metals Supply Tightens as Oil Shipping Costs Fall

At the Silver Institute’s Annual Industry Supply Dinner in NY, Metals Focus’ Managing Director Philip...

When Does a Market Selloff Become a Financial Crisis? | Steve Hanke
Video

When Does a Market Selloff Become a Financial Crisis? | Steve Hanke

Steve Hanke connects the artificial intelligence investment boom with growing credit risk. The article explains how losses could spread, what historical crisis research establishes and which financial buffers could contain the damage.

Protecting Stock Market Gains: Albert Lu’s Approach to Risk
Video

Protecting Stock Market Gains: Albert Lu’s Approach to Risk

Albert Lu discusses preserving market gains without chasing a rebound. His conversation with Maggie Lake covers technology concentration, cash, bonds, precious metals, credit and long-term opportunities.

Enjoyed This? Get More Insights

Expert insights and curated opportunities, delivered to your inbox.

    By subscribing, you agree to receive Wealthion emails. Unsubscribe anytime.

    Ready to Position for What's Coming?

    Whether you're still learning or ready to act, your next step starts here.

    Explore Opportunities
    • Independent
    • Macro-Informed
    • Real Asset Focused
    Gold
    Newsletter Modal